The reveal of River Song's identity delights us while the reveal of Mels just confuses us. Find out to when we'd like to time travel, how we'd feel in Amy's position, and why we think Moffat was off his game this time.
BBC America Brings Destroyed Doctor Who Episodes Back to Life [BBC America]
We asked you: What would be in your hotel room? (Your greatest fear)
Join in the fun by sending us your answers to this episode's question via email or Twitter! Listen on iTunes, Podbean, or right here using the player below!